+
2 Tutorials that teach Applying Conventionalism
Take your pick:
Applying Conventionalism

Applying Conventionalism

Author: John Lumsden
Description:

Given a situation, apply conventionalism

(more)
See More
Try a College Course Free

Sophia’s self-paced online courses are a great way to save time and money as you earn credits eligible for transfer to over 2,000 colleges and universities.*

Begin Free Trial
No credit card required

25 Sophia partners guarantee credit transfer.

221 Institutions have accepted or given pre-approval for credit transfer.

* The American Council on Education's College Credit Recommendation Service (ACE Credit®) has evaluated and recommended college credit for 20 of Sophia’s online courses. More than 2,000 colleges and universities consider ACE CREDIT recommendations in determining the applicability to their course and degree programs.

Tutorial
In this tutorial we will look at the relationship between our everyday ethical views and conventionalism. We will also consider how conventionalism can be applied to certain ethical issues. Our discussion will break down like this:
  1. Agreement with Everyday Morality
  2. Disagreement with Everyday Morality
  3. Some Uncertain Cases
  4. Topics in Applied Ethics


1. Agreement with Everyday Morality

To begin with, recall that conventionalism is a relativist theory of ethics that maintains that what is good is determined relative to a society, convention, or culture. On this account, no society or culture is better than another.

Sometimes our intuitive or everyday views about right and wrong match up with what the conventionalist says about morality.

A conventionalist in just about any culture will say that cannibalism is generally wrong. The impermissibility of cannibalism makes sense to most of us.

Another common ethical view is that health care of some kind is needed in any well-functioning society. A conventionalist will see that most cultures find health care beneficial and thus say it is morally desirable.


2. Disagreement with Everyday Morality

Much of what you find intuitively right or wrong is learned from the society you’re brought up in. Thus, if you’re a conventionalist, your intuitions are likely to match up with the ethical evaluations you make with this theory.

Consider the overlap of intuitions and conventions on the issue of workplace interaction between men and women.

If you're American you are likely to be intuitively neutral about this. Since it is North America a conventionalist will say it's permissible.  If you're in Saudi Arabia, you're likely to be intuitively against this. Since it is widely rejected in Saudi Arabia, a conventionalist will say it's impermissible.


It should be noted that a Saudi Arabian might find the impermissibility of men and women interacting in the workplace counterintuitive. In this case they will be in disagreement with the conventionalist in their own country, but in agreement with the conventionalist in America.

There are other ways that your moral intuitions might go against the conventionalist. For instance, your views might not fit with how your own society works.

Most American’s intuitively think child labor is wrong. But since cheap clothing, for instance, is supplied to this country through the exploitation of child labor, a conventionalist will say that it is morally permissible.


3. Some Uncertain Cases

Sometimes it is not clear whether or not our everyday moral views fit with the conventionalist. This is sometimes due to the fact that there isn’t a consensus on an issue in a particular society.

In Britain, as in many countries, there is a split between those that think eating meat is wrong, and those that think it isn’t wrong. Therefore, conventionalism cannot come up with a clear answer on whether or not eating meat is impermissible in places such as Britain.

Another issue that divides a population is the use of recreational drugs.

People from many countries think that some recreational drugs are permissible, as long as people are adequately educated about them. Other people think that recreational drugs lead to other, more damaging, behaviors, and are therefore impermissible.

Here, there is a conflict between those that think drugs are bad for society and those that think they do not necessarily cause harm to society. For the conventionalist, then, it is undecided as to whether it is permissible or impermissible.


4. Topics in Applied Ethics

Philosophers working in ethics often try to apply ethical theories to specific situations. Let’s consider how conventionalists might apply their ethics to the following issues (assuming they are American).

  1. The moral permissibility of damaging the environment
  2. The moral permissibility of abortion
  3. The moral permissibility of contraception

Here are the positions that conventionalists takes on these issues.

Conventionalism and Applied Ethics
Environment People disagree about whether or not non-human nature has a moral status. Therefore, a conventionalist would give an uncertain result.
Abortion People are divided over this. Some think it is acceptable, others think it is unacceptable. A conventionalist would give an uncertain result.
Contraception Most people think the use of contraception is acceptable. A conventionalist would therefore say it is permissible.


If you disagree with the judgments based on what is accepted or what contributes to the functioning of a society, then you may not think conventionalism is the best ethical theory.


We started this tutorial by seeing how conventionalism can be in agreement with everyday morality, and then how it can be in disagreement with everyday morality. We saw that ethics based on society or culture sometimes fits with our common judgments, and sometimes does not.

Then we looked at some uncertain cases where conventionalism couldn’t give clear evaluations because of a lack of consensus among people in a particular place. Finally, some topics in applied ethics were considered from the perspective of conventionalism.

Source: Office workers image, public domain, http://bit.ly/2bwjPhu